Originally, it didn't seem like Istanbul could hold a straw to Rome. Although it was incredible in its own rite, Rome is... well, the Eternal City. But looking back on the trip as a whole, I think my perspective has changed. While I visited Rome, I experienced Istanbul. If you merely visit Istanbul, it will be worthwhile. If you experience it, you'll never forget it.
The Hostel: Mavi Guesthouse
Breakfast everyday consisted of slices of tomato and cucumber, a hard boiled egg, cream cheese and jelly, and an endless supply of sliced bread with coffee and apple tea (a Turkish staple!). One of my bunk buddies was an enormous bald Turkish guy who worked at the hostel, and after a few days, he had our eating preferences down and brought our food immediately with a smile. Ali, the hostel owner, was an endless fount of information and advice, as well as an offbeat sense of humor that continually caught me by surprise.
The Blue Mosque

Inside was spacious and colorful... in a subdued sort of way. Women already praying lined the walls while tourists flashed their pictures. An unfortunate [ugly] American girl seemed to have forgotten to take her shoes off and got into an embarrassingly loud argument with one of the mosque men who was quietly asking her to leave. A few minutes later, that same man returned and herded us all out as quickly as possible right before the call to prayer thundered from the minarets. The whole city echoed with the various mosques' calls as the sun began to set. It was beautiful.
The Hagia Sophia

Jimmy and the Asian Side
Let's be honest: crossing into whole other continent for the price of a 2 Turkish Lira ferry ticket is pretty incredible. The city didn't change at all, but I did get to add another checkmark to my To-Do List for Life! We went without a clear agenda, and after wandering around, we decided to find the TV tower hill for a 360 of the city. The only thing was, we had no idea where it was. An older gentleman just happened to overhear us wondering out loud and offered to show us the way. As it turned out, he (Jimmy) was an ex-journalist and diplomat, and he resurrected 25-year-old English with little difficulty.
The hill entailed a bus ride and a sharp walk upward. Jimmy accompanied us the whole way and was an endless source of knowledge and conversation. While some of us were worried he'd turn around and demand millions of dollars at any moment, the rest of us enjoyed a lively conversation. He seemed to take a balanced perspective on most things, whether the Kurds, or gypsies, or censorship, or Turkey's pending admittance to the EU.
At the top, we stopped for Turkish coffee and dessert. I'm not typically a fan of chocolate lava cakes, but whatever we ate blew that away. It was delicious. Afterwards, Jimmy explained their tradition of reading fortunes from the coffee grounds left in the bottom of the coffee cups. The descriptions were humorous, at best, but it should be noted that Will's involved an Evil Eye (common in Turkey), and less than 24 hours later he had a whopper of an eye infection. When he mustered enough strength to find a pharmacy, people would stop him on the street: "My friend, my friend! Your eye is going to explode!"
The Whirling Dervishes

While waiting in line to see the Hagia Sophia, someone gave us a flyer to a whirling dervish performance that evening. Dervishes, as you may know, are the mystic clerics in Sufism, and they dance in circles in a set ceremony as a spiritual practice and entrance into meditation. Intrigued and wishing I'd brought my Rumi book of poems (which actually did make it to Spain!), I put it on my If-We-Have-Time-and-Money-I'd-Really-Like-to-Go list. The timing worked perfectly, though it meant we had to scarf down the world's greatest kebab en route. (I kid you not, most kebabs are pretty similar. This one was divine.) The performance itself was cool, but it was definitely helpful to have an explanation of the ceremony in front of us!
Turkish Baths
The Grand Bazaar
The Grand Bazaar is an enormous market in a catacomb-like building that stretched on and on and sold everything from soap to leather and Persian rugs to jewels. It really puts Disney to shame... it was like Aladdin on steroids. So many people, so many products, everyone shouting and vying for attention, some of the vendors genuinely interested and others 100% sleazy. It was fun to see the sights and haggle over a few things, but it was exhausting. There is a pretty good chance that the lamp I bought didn't make it to Athens and Rome and Madrid completely intact. I still haven't opened the bad to see. Yikes. Superglue maybe?
Most Unexpected Moment
Favorite Second-Hand Story
(told without permission... sorry Kelly!)
One of the nights, most of our group opted to go to Taksim, the nightlife hub of Istanbul. Ready to call it a day, I declined but wished them a good time. Off they went. They arrived at a huge club, only to find that it was mostly deserted except for the fourth floor. The bouncer, however, was not very understanding and flatly refused to admit them. Kelly and Tina watched from a distance as the Wills tried to argue (sweet-talk) their way in. Defeated, they returned to the girls with the bad news. It was a no go. Not ready to give in, Kelly spoke up. "Step aside, Will, let me handle this."
Now, you need to know that Kelly is a few inches shorter than me, has beautiful eyes, and is altogether gorgeous. In fact, as Evil Eye Will put it, "You just so adorable, it's disgusting!" So Kelly walks up to the bouncer and smiles sweetly. "Is there any way we could go up to the fourth floor, please?" she asks.
"For you," the big man grinned, "no problem. Open sesame!" And that was that. The boys followed in silence :)